An investor can be optimistic about stocks over the long run and still want to limit some of the downside in a portion of the portfolio. Another may want an investment that can earn a return even if the market makes little progress. Those objectives lead to different decisions about how to invest.
Custom structured notes give us a way to shape how an investment responds to market movements. At Bishop Capital Advisors, we consider them within the context of a client’s overall portfolio, with a specific purpose for the money and a clear understanding of the trade-offs.
A structured note is a debt obligation issued by a financial institution. It combines a debt component with derivatives that establish how payments are calculated, usually by reference to a stock index, individual stocks, or other assets. You own the note, not the referenced investments. The issuer’s ability to pay matters throughout: Even a note with principal protection can result in a substantial or total loss if the issuer and any guarantor cannot meet their obligations.
The design process begins with the role we want the investment to serve. We consider:
- Market exposure: Which index, stocks, or other assets should determine the note’s return?
- Holding period: How long can the client commit this portion of the portfolio?
- Return structure: Should the note emphasize market participation, conditional payments, or a combination of the two?
- Downside terms: What happens if the reference investment declines, and when are those conditions measured?
Financial institutions issue and price the notes. Our role is to design and evaluate the combination of terms around the client’s objectives, subject to available market pricing.
For example, a note may offer enhanced participation in market gains up to a maximum return, alongside specified downside terms. Accepting that cap may make sense for a particular objective, but it also means giving up gains if the market rises beyond it. Other structures can retain uncapped upside, with different concessions elsewhere in the design.
One approach combines a conditional fixed return at maturity with the ability to participate in larger market gains. In some structures, the fixed return is payable even if the reference investment finishes flat or moderately lower, provided the stated condition is met. If it rises enough, the investor instead receives a return linked to that stronger performance, potentially without a cap. If the downside condition is not met, the fixed return may disappear and principal can be lost under the note’s loss formula. All payments remain subject to issuer credit risk.
That illustrates how different features can work together. We can consider whether a structure addresses a client’s concern about a lackluster market while retaining participation in a stronger one. The appeal depends on what the investor accepts in exchange, including the loss exposure, holding period, and dividends they generally forgo.
The downside language deserves close attention. A buffer and a barrier can sound similar, but their consequences can be very different.
With a straightforward buffer, the note absorbs a specified initial portion of the reference investment’s decline at maturity; losses beyond that portion fall to the investor under the note’s formula. With a contingent barrier, breaching the threshold under the specified observation rules can expose the investor to the full decline from the starting level. That can create a sharp change in the outcome. The exact terms, including when the condition is measured, govern both structures.
The choice of reference investments is equally important. A note linked to several stocks may base its payment on the worst-performing stock, rather than their average. Gains in the other stocks would not offset that result. Adding more names to this type of note does not necessarily diversify the investor’s risk. A higher potential payment needs to be evaluated alongside the conditions that could prevent it from being paid.
The holding period also matters. Downside terms generally apply at maturity, and the price shown on an account statement before then can move substantially. A secondary market may be limited or unavailable. Selling early can produce a significant loss even when the referenced investment has not breached the note’s downside threshold.
Costs and taxes belong in the decision as well. A note’s initial estimated value may be below its purchase price because of embedded selling, structuring, and hedging costs. Applicable advisory fees further affect investor returns. Tax treatment varies and can be complex. Some notes can also be redeemed early, shortening the expected investment period and creating a need to reinvest on different terms.
We view equity-linked notes as part of the portfolio’s market exposure, with their own conditions and risks. That means considering them alongside existing stock holdings, issuer exposure, and the cash a client needs available. A note’s usefulness depends on how it fits that larger picture and whether its terms justify the risks and limitations the client is taking on.
Our work is to connect those details to an investment decision the client can understand: why the note belongs in the portfolio, how it may respond to different markets, and what could go wrong.
Important Disclosures
This material is provided by Bishop Capital Advisors LLC for informational and educational purposes only. It is not personalized investment, tax, or legal advice, or a recommendation to purchase a specific security. The structures described are general explanations, not current offerings or promises of results. Investment decisions should reflect an investor’s objectives, financial circumstances, liquidity needs, and risk tolerance.
Structured notes are complex, unsecured debt obligations and are not FDIC-insured. Investors may lose some or all of their principal. Payments and any principal protection depend on the issuer’s and any guarantor’s ability to meet their obligations. Downside features are subject to each note’s specific terms and do not protect against issuer default. Notes may have limited liquidity, conditional payments, capped returns, or early redemption provisions. Review the applicable prospectus, pricing supplement, and risk disclosures before investing.